Tenant Failed Referencing: What Are Your Options?
A failed reference tells you someone missed a threshold, not that they won't pay. Here are the four options open to a landlord holding one, what each costs, and why standard rent guarantee insurance usually won't help.
TLDR: If your tenant failed referencing, you can let to them anyway, ask for a guarantor, have them reassessed by a provider that covers its own assessment, or re-advertise. Standard rent guarantee insurance usually won't cover a tenant who failed, so find out why they failed before you decide.
Your prospective tenant has failed referencing, and now you have a decision to make. It's an awkward spot: you may like the applicant, the property is sitting empty, and the report gives you a verdict without much of a reason. We think a failed reference is worth a second look, so let's go through what it actually means and the four options open to you.
You can:
- Have them reassessed by a provider whose cover doesn't depend on a conventional reference
- Ask for a guarantor, if they have one who qualifies
- Let to them as they are, and carry the risk yourself
- Decline and re-advertise
Most landlords take the fourth, often because they don't know the first exists. But an empty week at the average rent in England is about £338 you won't get back, plus re-marketing time, another round of referencing, and no guarantee the next applicant passes either.
What does a failed tenant reference actually mean?
The reason for the fail matters far more than the fail itself, and it should decide what you do next. Tenants usually fail for one of four reasons: adverse credit, an affordability gap, income that doesn't come from a standard payslip, or a poor rental history.
Referencing providers apply fixed rules, most commonly no CCJs, IVAs or bankruptcies, plus a yearly income of 30 times the monthly rent. An applicant earning slightly under that fails, even when their bank statements show years of rent paid on time. So does someone with a satisfied £100 CCJ for a parking ticket from two years ago.
A fabricated employer reference and a self-employed contractor whose income the system couldn't verify are very different problems, but the report shows them the same way: a fail. So ask the referencing provider or the applicant which check they failed before you decide. Our guide to tenant referencing explains what each check looks at.
Can I let to a tenant who failed referencing?
Yes. Landlords do it every day, especially when the reason for the fail is one they can look past. Referencing isn't a legal requirement, and the result is a recommendation rather than a ruling.
What matters is the protection you'll have if the tenancy goes wrong, and that's where most landlords run into a problem with standard rent guarantee insurance.
Why don't the usual workarounds work any more?
In England, three of the tools landlords used to reach for have gone.
Rent in advance is capped. Since 1 May 2026, landlords can't ask for more than one month's rent upfront, so the old way to offset a thin reference is no longer available.
Section 21 has gone. Ending a tenancy now needs a specific ground and takes longer, which raises the cost of getting this decision wrong.
Blanket policies have gone too. Since 1 May 2026, it's unlawful to refuse a tenant because they receive benefits or have children, and each application needs to be assessed on its own merits. A professional referencing decision is an individual assessment, so relying on one is a defensible position. It just means the reference carries more weight than it used to.
Can I get rent guarantee insurance if my tenant failed referencing?
Usually not. Most guides tell landlords in this position to take out rent guarantee insurance, and it's sensible advice that usually can't be followed.
Standard rent guarantee policies require every tenant to have passed referencing, either on their own or with a guarantor who passes. If you go ahead without that, you're self-insuring: no insurer will pay out on that tenancy.
How do the four options compare?
| Option | What it costs you now | What arrears would cost you | Cover available | Best when |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Let to them as they are | Nothing | Everything: you carry all the risk | No | A small, old CCJ on an otherwise strong application |
| Ask for a guarantor | Nothing | Your excess, if you have rent guarantee insurance | Yes, if the guarantor passes referencing | The tenant has a UK homeowner earning 36 times the monthly rent |
| Reassess with Husmus | An upfront assessment fee, with results in 24 to 36 hours | Nothing up to your policy limits, apart from the deposit if you took one | Yes, based on the new assessment | You want a quick decision and full cover |
| Decline and re-advertise | Empty days (about £48 a day at the average rent in England), plus re-marketing and new referencing | Not applicable | Not applicable | The fail revealed something you can't look past |
Scroll sideways to see all columns.
Reassess with Husmus
Have the applicant assessed on what they can actually afford, rather than on a fixed multiple, and take cover based on that assessment. It's the option most landlords don't know about, because standard rent guarantee insurance can't offer it. You pay for the assessment upfront. If the applicant doesn't pass, you can simply send us more applicants to assess, and as soon as one passes, everything moves ahead.
Ask for a guarantor
This is the strongest position on paper and the hardest to reach. A qualifying guarantor usually needs a yearly income of around 36 times the monthly rent, a UK base and a clean credit history, and most landlords also want a homeowner. On a £1,200 property, that's someone earning £43,200, and many perfectly good tenants can't produce that person. When they can, the guarantee is only as good as the document, so make sure it's signed properly as a deed, with the tenancy agreement attached. Our guide to human guarantors and guarantor insurance covers the trade-offs.
Let to them as they are
This costs nothing today, but you carry all of the arrears risk, the damage risk beyond the deposit and the legal costs if it ends badly, with no cover to fall back on. It's reasonable for a small, old, satisfied CCJ on an otherwise strong application. The odds are poor when the fail was for affordability, because the numbers don't improve after move-in.
Decline and re-advertise
This is the default choice, and its cost is usually invisible. A month empty at the average rent in England is £1,466, before re-marketing and fresh referencing. Weigh that against the chance that the next applicant clears every threshold. Declining still costs you money: you just pay it in empty days rather than arrears.
How does the Husmus route work?
A conventional reference fails a tenant who can pay because it asks whether they clear a fixed multiple, rather than whether they pay their rent. We ask the second question. We verify income through Open Banking, look at several years of financial history, check it against HMRC and payroll records, and run biometric identity and fraud checks. A CCJ is part of the picture, and we look at it alongside everything else.
Because we assess the tenant and provide the cover, a Husmus pass doesn't get turned down by someone else further down the line. Where the assessment supports it, Rent Shield covers up to 12 months of unpaid rent, on rents up to £10,000 a month, plus up to £5,000 of damage beyond the deposit and eviction legal costs up to £20,000. You can claim from day 7 of a missed payment, and we aim to decide within 14 days and pay within 7 days after that. You pay, your tenant pays, or you split it, if your tenant chooses to.
Assessments come back within 24 to 36 hours. So for the applicant sitting in your inbox, the choice may be between an empty property and a let with more protection than a passing tenant would have brought you.
Frequently asked questions
Should I just ask for a larger deposit?
Deposits are capped at five weeks' rent for most tenancies in England, so this doesn't scale to the risk. Five weeks of deposit against twelve months of possible arrears won't get you very far.
Does a guarantor fix a failed credit check?
For your own risk, partly. For insurance, often not, because some rent guarantee policies exclude the tenancy outright when the tenant failed a credit check, whatever the guarantor's position.
Should I tell the tenant why they failed?
It helps, because some fails are easy to fix, such as a wrong address or a missing payslip. They can also ask the referencing company for a copy of the information it holds about them.
Holding a failed reference right now? Get the applicant assessed with Husmus and find out whether the fail was a threshold problem or a real one.
Correct as at 5 November 2026. This guide covers England.